|
A Place
In the Sun (1951)
In Best Director-winning George Stevens' classic tearjerker
based upon Theodore Dreiser's An American Tragedy - a star-crossed
melodramatic romance (and social drama) set in 1950:
- in the opening, low-born, ambitious George Eastman
(Montgomery Clift) from Chicago hitched a ride to his distant,
wealthy Uncle Charles Eastman's (Herbert Heyes) place, where he
sought employment at his Uncle's bathing suit factory as a low-level
worker
- the powerful romantic chemistry that developed between
George Eastman and snobbish, beautiful, well-bred rich socialite
Angela Vickers (Elizabeth Taylor) - his own distant cousin
- in the meantime, George began to date (against company
policies) and eventually impregnated poor, lower-class factory co-worker
Alice Tripp (Shelley Winters); in her cramped one-room apartment
while serving the very tardy George his birthday dinner, she confessed: "George,
it's awful. I can't tell you now....Oh, I'm so afraid...George, I'm
in trouble - real trouble, I think...Remember the first night we
came here. Oh, I'm so worried"
- the first of two starry-eyed, sensuous romantic scenes
between George and Angela: (1) the dance scene: George appeared sullen,
deep and far away (due to the fact that he had impregnated a co-worker),
so he confessed his love to Angela, a love of an ideal woman which
had now been discovered in her: "I love you. I've loved you
since the first moment I saw you. I guess maybe I've loved you before
I saw you"; Angela then began to confess her love too, but then
became totally self-conscious, looking around anxiously and hesitantly: "You're
the fellow who wondered why I invited you here tonight. Well, I'll
tell you why. I love...Are they watching us?" - and s he pulled
him out to the balcony terrace for privacy
Dancing Sequence
|
|
|
George's Sullen Look
|
"Aren't you happy with me?"
|
|
|
"I've loved you since the first moment I
saw you"
|
"Are they watching us?"
|
- (2) the balcony scene: once on the balcony, she
replied reticently to his confession: "I love you too. It
scares me. But it is a wonderful feeling"; extreme closeups
filled the screen as they revealed innermost emotions and inflamed
passions; George was filled with guilt and repression: "Oh,
Angela, if I could only tell you how much I love you, if I could
only tell you all."
She comforted him with an intimate reply while pulling him closer
to her:
"Tell Mama, tell Mama all"; they embraced and kissed passionately
(a soft-focus kiss in gigantic close-up)
- a doctor refused to terminate Alice's unwanted pregnancy
(the term abortion was not used); as a result, Alice used coercive
blackmail and insisted on an immediate marriage with George: ("I'll
tell them everything George, I mean it") - she confronted George
on the phone and threatened to reveal their relationship and pregnancy,
and even mentioned committing suicide; on Labor Day weekend at the
Vickers' lakeside home, Alice arrived in town to speak to George,
and insisted that they go to the county clerk's office to get married
immediately - but it was closed for the holiday
- the scene of the infamous lake/rowboat "murder" -
during a rowboat ride with Alice out into the middle of Loon Lake
on a dark night, George contemplated, planned and willed (if not
actually committed) the murder of his fiancee; however, at the last
crucial moment, he realized that he could not bring himself to carry
out his murderous evil plan ("I'll make it up to you. I'll stick
by you") by overturning the boat and letting her drown; but
then, in an ironic twist of fate, when she stood up to embrace him
and console him ("Oh, poor George. I know it isn't easy for
you. I shouldn't have said that"), she unbalanced the boat and
caused it to rock and capsize; she accidentally fell in and drowned,
and he was unable (or unwilling) to save her; the scene ended in
a very long shot of the overturned rowboat, and transitioned to a
dark, blurry dissolve into the next scene; George attempted to delay
dealing with the fact of Alice's death, but was soon confronted and
arrested by authorities: ("Is your name George Eastman?...You're
under arrest")
The Lake - Rowboat "Murder" Sequence
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Boat Capsized
|
Overturned Rowboat
|
"Is your name George Eastman?...You're under
arrest!"
|
- during a dramatic courtroom trial, George faced
murder charges, and confessed that he intended to murder Alice,
but there were no witnesses that he actually did; there was only
strong circumstantial evidence against him; the relentless District
Attorney R. Frank Marlowe (Raymond Burr, TV's future Perry Mason)
devastated George on the stand; he even re-enacted the rowboat
death in the courtroom, while George failed to credibly answer
questions and help to reconstruct the drowning -- the most dramatic
moment in the courtroom came when Marlowe struck the oar across
the boat, implying that George had struck Alice and caused her
to fall into the water
- the final prison/execution farewell scene in the death
cell between condemned and doomed poor boy George before his execution
with Angela, wearing black (with a white collar): (Angela: "...I'll
go on loving you for as long as I live." George: "Love
me for the time I have left. Then, forget me." (They kissed
one last time.) Angela: "Goodbye, George." (She half-turned
away and then looked back.) "Seems like we always spend the
best part of our time just saying goodbye"); George took to
his death the superimposed image of dark-haired Angela kissing him
|
George in Opening Credits - Hitchhiking
George's Forbidden Relationship with Co-Worker Alice
Alice's Startling Confession of Pregnancy
Balcony Love Scene: "Tell Mama, tell Mama all"
Alice Coercively Confronting George: "I'll
tell them everything"
Courtroom Trial: George on Witness Stand Brutally
Questioned by DA Frank Marlowe (Raymond Burr)
Final Prison Farewell Scene
|